The nature-rights movement isn’t primarily concerned with conserving or responsibly managing our natural resources. Instead, it aims to limit human activities and development by granting legal rights to natural entities.
Although the concept may sound appealing on the surface, the town of Nederland in Colorado has learned the hard way about the unintended consequences of implementing “rights of nature” policies, particularly concerning waterways. Initially, town leaders embraced the idea to protect local rivers, appointing guardians to oversee potential threats to water quality and flow.
However, the town’s enthusiasm waned when it realized the potential implications for its own development plans, such as constructing a dam. Mayor Billy Giblin acknowledged the need to balance environmental ideals with practical considerations for the community’s welfare and security.
The problem with nature rights is their lack of nuance in addressing complex environmental issues. While traditional environmental laws allow for a balanced approach that considers human needs alongside conservation efforts, nature rights prioritize the interests of natural entities above all else. This one-sided approach often leads to conflicts between environmental preservation and human well-being.
Nature-rights proponents, like Gary Wockner of Save the World’s Rivers, remain steadfast in their opposition to projects like dams, arguing that they irreparably harm rivers. However, this perspective overlooks the significant benefits dams provide, such as water storage, flood control, recreation, and electricity generation.
Ultimately, it’s essential for leaders to carefully consider the broader implications of nature-rights policies and prioritize decisions that benefit both the environment and the community as a whole. This requires a balanced approach that considers all aspects of a situation, rather than prioritizing the interests of natural entities over human welfare.
By reassessing and potentially repealing nature-rights resolutions, communities like Nederland can make more informed decisions about their environmental policies and development projects, ensuring a sustainable future for both humans and nature.
